Bike Perfect Verdict
The XC3s are a comfortable, well-featured, decent-value BOA shoe for MTB or gravel, with a great size range. Add in good stability on XC and more technical terrain, low weight, stiffness that balances pedalling vs hike-a-bike, plus good grip, and they should definitely be on your list if you’re looking for a value option.
Pros
- +
Good price for a BOA shoe
- +
Decent compromise of power transfer to flex
- +
Lightweight
- +
Grippy tread
- +
Great size range (36-52) and a womens' model
Cons
- -
Fewer sizes and no wide-fit option in US
- -
No toe spikes option
Why trust BikePerfect Our cycling experts have decades of testing experience. We\'ll always share our unbiased opinions on bikes and gear. Find out more about how we test.
In 1990, Shimano introduced the SPD (Shimano Pedaling Dynamics) cleat system and the M100 off-road shoe. Several factory race teams from XC to enduro to downhill wear Shimano shoes. Following Bike Perfect’s piece on Shimano's new XC1 and XC3 shoes, how do the XC3s stack up against the best budget MTB shoes out there?
Design and specification
The XC3s have a sleek, minimal design. Rather than a conventional tongue, one side of the synthetic leather upper wraps over the other on the bridge of the foot. For breathability, there is a small mesh section at the base of the bridge, and the uppers are perforated around the front of the foot. There’s a toe kicker, and a stiffened and padded heel, which feels nicely squishy. The inside is microfibre, apart from synthetic leather lining the heel. Wrapping things up (literally), the shoes fasten via the ‘BOA Fit System‘: twisting the dial ratchets plastic wires laced across the foot bridge. As with Bike Perfect’s current best bargain clipless shoe, the Carnac Grit, this is unusual for shoes at this price point.
Shimano's XC3s sport a shallow glass fiber-reinforced nylon outsole – like the Carnac Grit, there is no shock absorption between the hard lattice top of the outsole and the removable insole, giving a low ‘stack height’ and profile.
The underside of the outsole is rubberized, with tread knobs around the heel, ball of the foot and toe box. Unlike the Carnac Grit or the next Shimano shoe up in the range (the XC5), there is no option for screwing in cyclocross-style toe spikes.
While the XC3s come in a fantastic size range in Europe (EU 36-52, in both standard and wide fit), they only come in US size 6½-16 (EU 40-52) and only in standard width in the US. There’s also a women’s specific XC3. Bont, Lake and Sidi go up to size 50 in a standard and wide fit, but the XC3s are the only off-the-shelf clipless MTB shoe, from any brand, in a size 51 or 52 wide fit … and I needed a clown-sized 52 wide!
Performance
I’ve pushed the XC3s beyond their XC envelope, having ridden and hike-a-biked big, technical British mountain epics in snow and slop, challenged my deathgrip nerve on bike park raids, done some cheeky gravel blasts and even a bit of road commuting.
So, how do they fit? Pretty well. Length was good, however, my feet are super-wide and my toes felt too squashed at the sides, meaning they got cold on sub-zero days (where my discontinued 51-wide Sidi Dominator 5s allowed toe wiggling and kept my feet toasty in the same conditions, even though their uppers are thinner). Having internal shoe width measurements on the Shimano size chart would help here when buying online (as Bont and Lake do).
Compromised toes aside, my feet felt comfortable, and on warmer days, never felt too hot (although I’ve not yet ridden them in very hot weather). My heel stayed securely in place, the BOA system and the outsole’s low-profile kept my foot stable on long, rowdy descents, giving great confidence. Power transfer felt decent, with some helpful outsole flex during some hour-plus steep hike-a-bike (Shimano rate the stiffness of the XC3s as 5 out of 12).
Tread grip was good on most wet rock and the tread is showing minimal wear so far. And despite much abuse, they still smell fresh! Once wet, the XC3s do take a couple of days to dry, though this is the case for most shoes. They feel pretty light, and the stated 664g for both shoes in a size 42 (with no cleats) is comparable to similarly priced shoes.
Verdict
The XC3s have stood up to a good thrashing on pure XC, plus plenty of chunkier rides, and also work for gravel or commuting. Fit, comfort, grip and weight are good, and the BOA system and low profile give a stable and confidence-inspiring platform. While not the stiffest shoes, they’re a decent compromise for a range of riding, and handle hike-a-bike stints well.
If you’re looking for a relatively budget choice then the XC3s should definitely be on your list, especially if you have unusually big or small feet.
| Attributes | Notes | Rating |
|---|---|---|
| Comfort | Really good apart from cold toes due to my super wide feet | ★★★★ |
| Grip | Impressive in all conditions | ★★★★★ |
| Power transfer | A good comfort vs stiffness ratio | ★★★ |
| Value for money | Feature packed and an excellent price | ★★★★★ |
Tech specs – Shimano XC3 (SH-XC300) shoes
- Price: $125.00 / £109.99
- Sizes: US: US size 6.5-16/EU 40-52 standard width only. Europe: EU 36-52 standard and wide-fit
- Colors: US: Olive, Black. Europe: Olive, White, Black
- Weight: 941g (pair of size 52 wide with cleats). 664g (42 standard-width no cleats) claimed
